Discussion:
Blazon/Heraldry Software
(too old to reply)
Seth H Holmes
2005-06-16 12:15:26 UTC
Permalink
Does anyone have a recommendation for software which can be used to
design/create/draw blazons/heraldry? I have used Blazons 95 and at one time
tried Blazons! 2000 (which is no longer available it would seem). Also
tried one other program that was entirely in french. Wondering if there's
anything newer available.

Thanks.
--
Seth H Holmes
Arval
2005-06-16 14:53:24 UTC
Permalink
Post by Seth H Holmes
Does anyone have a recommendation for software which can be used to
design/create/draw blazons/heraldry? I have used Blazons 95 and at one time
tried Blazons! 2000 (which is no longer available it would seem). Also
tried one other program that was entirely in french. Wondering if there's
anything newer available.
I don't; but I do have a general caution: I've never seen
heraldry-design software that contained any intelligence about
_period_ designs. Just because you can build it doesn't mean it's a
good re-creation of pre-16th century heraldry from the culture you
want to re-create.

===========================================================================
Arval ***@mittle.users.panix.com
Seth H Holmes
2005-06-16 17:28:47 UTC
Permalink
Post by Arval
Post by Seth H Holmes
Does anyone have a recommendation for software which can be used to
design/create/draw blazons/heraldry? I have used Blazons 95 and at one time
tried Blazons! 2000 (which is no longer available it would seem). Also
tried one other program that was entirely in french. Wondering if there's
anything newer available.
I don't; but I do have a general caution: I've never seen
heraldry-design software that contained any intelligence about
_period_ designs. Just because you can build it doesn't mean it's a
good re-creation of pre-16th century heraldry from the culture you
want to re-create.
It will get me started in the right direction, however.
--
Seth H Holmes
Arval
2005-06-16 18:52:44 UTC
Permalink
I've never seen heraldry-design software that contained any
intelligence about _period_ designs. Just because you can build it
doesn't mean it's a good re-creation of pre-16th century heraldry
from the culture you want to re-create.
It will get me started in the right direction, however.
Not really, if your goal is to end up with arms that fit well into
some medieval culture. Most of the charges that the program offers
will not be appropriate for most cultures. Many other choices won't
be, either. The artistic style will certainly be modern.

Here's an analogy: Suppose I gave you a piece of software that allows
you design houses. Do you think it would be a good starting point for
designing a 15th century townhouse that might have been found in the
better neighborhoods of Milan? It might -- perhaps -- contain the
features you would need to design such a house, but if you didn't know
which elements to use, the chances are almost 100% that you'd end up
with the wrong thing.

Heraldry software can be useful in preparing drawings of a design if
you aren't good at drawing. If you have other sources to guide you on
designs appropriate for your medieval culture, then it might be a
useful tool in trying out designs. But don't mistake it for a useful
_design_ tool if your goal is to re-create something plausibly
medieval.

===========================================================================
Arval ***@mittle.users.panix.com
Seth H Holmes
2005-06-17 13:43:39 UTC
Permalink
Post by Arval
Heraldry software can be useful in preparing drawings of a design if
you aren't good at drawing. If you have other sources to guide you on
designs appropriate for your medieval culture, then it might be a
useful tool in trying out designs. But don't mistake it for a useful
_design_ tool if your goal is to re-create something plausibly
medieval.
You've hit the nail on the head. I'm not good at drawing. This is what I
need the software for. I have reference to the rules of heraldry and thus I
can work within those guildlines. But the software gives me the chance to
view the creation to see how it will look. And it may give me idea which I
hadn't thought of, which I can later cross check to see if they fit in with
the rules of heraldry.
--
Seth H Holmes
Arval
2005-06-17 19:54:53 UTC
Permalink
Post by Seth H Holmes
You've hit the nail on the head. I'm not good at drawing. This is what I
need the software for.
Perfectly reasonable.
Post by Seth H Holmes
I have reference to the rules of heraldry and thus I can work within
those guildlines.
Another caution: The SCA's rules for submissions are _not_ a good
guide to any medieval heraldic style. They are minimal standards that
bar the most egregious inauthenticities, but there's a great deal
that's inauthentic that's still well within the rules.

The best general guide I can suggest for period heraldic style is
Joseph Foster's book The Dictionary of Heraldry (New York: Arch Cape
Press, 1989). The title is misleading: It's really an armorial, a
collection of arms from 13th-15th century English rolls of arms. Most
usefully, it contains several thousand color drawings of some of those
arms, in period artistic styles. Of course, it only covers English
heraldry; but most of what's there would not be out of place in many
European countries. It's a good starting point and reasonably
accessible.

===========================================================================
Arval ***@mittle.users.panix.com
Seth H Holmes
2005-06-20 13:47:56 UTC
Permalink
Post by Arval
Another caution: The SCA's rules for submissions are _not_ a good
guide to any medieval heraldic style. They are minimal standards that
bar the most egregious inauthenticities, but there's a great deal
that's inauthentic that's still well within the rules.
This is not for use within the SCA. This just seemed like a good resource
for information.
d***@earthlink.net
2005-06-20 21:01:01 UTC
Permalink
Post by Seth H Holmes
Does anyone have a recommendation for software which can be used to
design/create/draw blazons/heraldry? I have used Blazons 95 and at one time
tried Blazons! 2000 (which is no longer available it would seem). Also
tried one other program that was entirely in french. Wondering if there's
anything newer available.
There is one more, published sometime last year on a CD-ROM in an
English genealogy magazine. It appears to be about a limited as the
others in most respects, and is inferior to the French one.

David

Loading...